Expert Opinion

morrison-7-aug
07Aug

Is Morrison’s West Ham career already unraveling?

by Mike Calvin avatar

The questions are inevitable, and thoroughly depressing. Is West Ham’s gamble on Ravel Morrison beginning to unravel? Is his move to Birmingham City, on a season’s loan, the beginning of the end? Was, once again, Sir Alex Ferguson correct, in allowing a supremely talented misfit to leave Manchester United?

Morrison is only 19, but he has attracted sufficient controversy for several lifetimes. His personal problems go before him and cloud judgements. He has played just 14 minutes of first-team football since moving to West Ham from Man Utd on transfer deadline day in January, in a deal which might eventually be worth £3m.

In retrospect, West Ham was the worst possible club to join. They lack a clear sense of direction and are burdened by an exaggerated sense of expectation. They are linked with a random collection of players in the transfer market, which indicates they have yet to develop a cohesive strategy for survival on their return to the Premier League.

Sam Allardyce’s friendship with Sir Alex ensured he knew what he was getting into with Morrison, who played three times for Man Utd, but effectively priced himself out of a future at Old Trafford. His departure was a source of regret, because United’s coaching staff privately raved about his potential as an attacking midfield player or second striker.

In a football sense, Morrison might benefit from a season of regular football in the Championship, under an intense, yet engaging, manager like Lee Clark. But, as so often in his short career, things are not that simple. Birmingham are in disarray, and will enter the new season under a cloud.

Owner Carson Yeung is on £1m bail, and banned from leaving Hong Kong until his trial in November, when he must answer five counts of money laundering. Birmingham’s finances are in a parlous state and they have little option but to cash in on their principal assets, such as goalkeeper Jack Butland.

Those close to Morrison feel he has been judged harshly. They paint a picture of an impressionable young man, who is determined to make up for past mistakes. A magistrate’s warning that he faced prison if he did not change his ways hit home, hard. He is ready to prove the doubters wrong.

You hope for the best, but fear the worst.

Related articles:

Video: Cole to Man Utd, Reds close on Dempsey, Carroll Toon return?

Video: Park, Diame and Sigurdsson – hit or miss?

Video: “Man Utd have become conservative in the transfer market”

Alexander Netherton: Man Utd don’t need another midfielder to regain title

Follow Life’s A Pitch on Twitter @BTLifesaPitch

Comments

Please leave your comments using the box below. Learn more

  • Sonnythebear

    Not sure transfer speculation in the newspapers can be used as an indication on a club’s strategy.

  • e17blue

    I doubt you’ll find many blues fans who think the club are under a cloud. Lee Clark has been told he doesn’t have to sell any more players and the club is generating enough money to sustain itself. The holding company has issues and certainly Carson Yeung is up the creek and looking like he’ll do some porridge, but BCFC have proved to the Football League they can survive without BIH interest. Thanks to the ground work by Chris Houghton, Lee Clark has a great platform to work from and the blues fans are behind him and the team!

  • StuFromSaturday

    That has got to be the biggest pile of utter bilge I have ever, ever read.  And I really do mean that.  Who on EARTH does Mike Calvin think he is to spout such utter guff - tosh that amounts to little more than thinly-disguised knocks at both West Ham AND Birmingham, under the heading of “expert” opinion???

    It would be laughable, if it weren’t for the fact that it really is so unbelievably sad.

    Appalling.

  • Redscot

    i would think as far as Manchester United are concerned Ravel Morrison is hitstory .He had several chances at one of the biggest club’s in the world to improve and correct his off the field stupidity . As he was clearly a youngster with a huge amount of promise and potential although totally un- fulfilled at our great club .The manager persevered with Ravel , hoping he would get his head straight to recognise it’s not just football ability , it’s also a need to recognise you need to keep working hard . Sir Alex Ferguson was correct in letting him leave for the Iron’s , as he could see the potential damage that could be done, to the group as a whole , by retaining Ravel on the United books .
    I understand he has even been sent home from West Ham’s summer tour for acting bizzarely  and requiring 7 teeth to be extracted back in England . So it would appear his personal hygiene is not up to scratch either at a young age.
    It’s all just a dreadfull shame for a youngster who had the world at his feet if he had just kept his head down , and learnt his trade alongside the great professionals at Manchester United.
    I partially blame the media for this ! . Talking up young football players in term’s such as stars , for them to read and hear this . It’s bound to affect their attitude and ambition . Lead them to believe they have ‘ made it ‘.
    As I don’t have a bad bone in my body , I can only wish Ravel Morrison all the best at the ‘ blue’s ‘ on his year – long loan . And hope he gets more game time than 14 minutes against Leed’s United ,than he did with West Ham .
    After Manchester United , there is generally only one way , you career will go that is down . The obvious exception Cristiano Ronaldo .
    Take not Paul Pogba at juventus.

  • Dclamp

    have to agree with other posters this article is factually incorrect and ill informed. blues are not under any cloud in fact the club have already said that its trading at a profit for this year and we dont need to sell anyone.
    my advise to you mate would be to get your facts right 

  • JohnnyZulu

    Unfortunately Michael you haven’t done your homework on Birmingham’s situation. The finances are now steady, they do NOT have to cash in on Butland and their squad is settled, there’s a fine atmosphere around the club and among the fans and they will be a serious contender for promotion. Yeung’s situation no longer makes any difference and new owners will be in to replace him within months.

  • Wozzie03

    Mike Calvin is a Millwall Fan FACT!! This is why he continually has digs at West Ham and will also dig at Brimingham because there fans gave Milwall a good hiding a few years back that was well publiscised.

    He is washed up and in fact why does his posts continue to be read when they contain nothing but facts that he makes up in his head, it’s a bit like his media career non existant apart from these unfactual comments of his own personal view that he makes on this website continuosly.

    He should be more worried about the satate of his beloved Milwall than clubs of a stature that they will never be. I am a West Ham fan granted but know the when golivan sold out to young thta they were the only premier league club to break even that year so where as MC states has there financial woes come from??

    Come on Mike Get a life and do some real journalistic work rather than picking up pieces of pointless information from other journalist’s stories and one you have dreamt about.

  • Getalife

    Errrrrr expert pmsl one that doesn’t know his ass from his earhole. Go and report on tiddlywinks.

  • Redscot

    You know what me eastender  mate . To call someone  ” washed up “  is very unfair . I quite like this forum , it’s provided some great fun and lively debate, in the past and I’m sure it will in the future . What I can’t understand  re- reading the thread , one Birmingham City fan made the point about the disagreement with Mike’s assessment  of the financial situation at St Andrews .The rest of the ‘ pack – Wolves ‘ then have to repeat the same laboured point .
    I’m not defended Mike Calvin , he would be more than capable of doing that himself , but to expect a ‘ journalist ‘ to respond to each little barbed dig at his integrity is not going to happen . They provide the base of the discussion . We debate as fan’s over the ‘ material ‘ provided .What I mean , is small time bloggers don’t even comment on peoples posts , in the main . I have seen a few columnist’s on the Bleacher Report , join in with the contributiors and it always makes for a lively friendly forum.Ed Barker on the fabulous United Rant’ does join in also in his forum. I would disagree with you Mike also  airs his views on national mediums like Talk Sport radio station , as an example. . Any occasion  I have heard Mike speaking he is always a great listen and informative.
    The point is I always think never shoot the messenger in a personal way . Shoot the arguement down by providing your own fact’s . Note the key point  ” Facts ” .
    I suppose you could write your own blog , Wozzie . if it contain’s as much information as your profile , that would be a snooze – fest.
    I apologise for my intial post , the  mis- spelling and the grammar is shocking. Anyhow I have work to do , thought I would just look back and see how it had developed .
    By the way points marked up to me doesn’t mean anything to me , what is in my profile and my fairminded nature does!
    Cheer’s. As i say just thought i would add my ‘ thoughts’ on Ravel Morrison . Work to do.

  • Claretblue

    How exactly do west ham lack a clear sense of direction? The owners have stabilised the club, significantly reduced debts they inherited, built a squad capable of getting out of the championship at the first time of asking and have now began showing a sense of ambition to sign international quality players and move into a 60000 capacity stadium in the next few years.
    What is a cohesive strategy to stay in the premier league? Please elaborate as that’s just a non-sense. Qpr, swansea and Norwich all stayed up, but there was no ‘cohesive strategy’ to qpr’s survival apart from having the luck that there were 3 teams even more abysmal than them despite their elaborate spending in the transfer windows.

  • John Byrne

     ”lack a clear sense of direction and are burdened by an exaggerated sense of expectation” – I dare you to tell Brady that face to face – what a turnip – hey there are more than 4 clubs in the country – with gobshites like you around we’d have a league made up of Chelsea, Arsenal, Man U and Man C – why have Liverpool and Spurs etc…the lack a clear sense of direction and are burdened by an exaggerated sense of expectation. What a complete doughnut

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_JUS5V6KQVPKC44MZDHUEG4VCGA mark

    Any news on his teeth!!!!

  • John Byrne

    Looks like Ray Winstone’s dad…but the shocked look on his face is telling…’oh dear, I got to think of something to write!!’

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/BD6SC6AQ7VRUGBCL3UBCJ432WI Chris

    mike you seem too know nothing think i would make a better reporter than you . i dont know who hired you but they should probably go for someone new and young because your the biggest waste of money and time 

  • GBK16

    West Ham lack a sense of direction? Are you talking out of your ass constantly? West Ham are a team on the up..All your articles are just blasting West Ham, cos your a jealous Millwall fan. Instead of constantly bitching about West Ham, try and find a story that actually makes sense, instead of one you make up in your head. Morrison has gone on loan because he will get experience in the Championship and is too big a risk to play in the PL right now. Now, go away back to your den and try to find something people actually care about

BT is not responsible for any external content or links uploaded by users of the site. Nor does the presence of information or links about other parties' products or services confer any form of endorsement of another party's products or services by BT. Please show respect to other users and avoid bad language when posting