Expert Opinion

mancini-17-jan
17Jan

Mancini still has lots to learn about the English game

by Mike Calvin avatar

Roberto Mancini may insist, with ill-concealed disdain, that “I know football”. But he has much to learn if he and Manchester City are not to continue to alienate their natural ally, the fair-minded fan.

Mancini’s petulant mime at the DW Stadium last night, which involved flourishing another imaginary red card, against Wigan defender Maynor Figueroa, was the act of a serial hypocrite. It was ignorant, indefensible and took the gloss off a victory that leaves Manchester City three points clear at the top of the Premier League.

The City manager was allowed to get away with it, during an obsequious post-match TV interview, but needs to be held to account. Fourth officials have enough to do, in the Punch and Judy show on the touchline, without the excesses of self-obsessed drama queens. The FA should be clear and unequivocal: if he does it again, Mancini will be sent to the stands, and banned for the next three games.

His strength of character, in dealing with pond life like Carlos Tevez, has been admirable. But his wilful failure to understand the culture in which he is working hints at the sense of entitlement that is one of the least attractive aspects of the City “project”.

We’ve already had to put up with his self-pitying whine about the depth of a squad that has been the centrepiece of a £1billion investment programme. UEFA’s financial fair play strategy may not be perfect, but it is necessary to level the playing field.

If Mancini wants to understand injustice, I suggest he contacts former Darlington manager Craig Liddle who, together with his players, was sacked by the administrator on Monday afternoon. Two of those players have not been paid since October.

If he wants to understand the need for prudence, he should examine the lunacy of incompetent clubs being freed from administration to repeat the mistake of paying players with money they simply do not have.

If he wants to understand the corrosive effect of institutionalised hypocrisy, he need only examine the Premier League’s deeply flawed youth football strategy, in which greed is hailed as progress.

Mancini won’t get any guidance from his assistant David Platt, one of those superannuated nodding dogs who find gainful employment in football. But he should listen to Brian Kidd, his most trusted coach.

Kidd is a fair man, a football man to his bootstraps. It was significant that he was the one, urging Mancini to walk away when the final whistle sounded at Wigan.

Related articles:

Video: “With Man City struggling, Spurs can win” Premier League

Mike Calvin: Man Utd’s FA Cup win over Man City merely masks flaws

Video: Man City advised against spending in January 

Video: “You wouldn’t blame Van Persie if he wanted to go to City”

Follow Mike Calvin on Twitter @CalvinBook 

Follow Life’s a Pitch on Twitter @BTLifesapitch

Watch Man City live on BT Vision:
Man City v Tottenham, live 1pm, 22 January, Sky Sports 1
Man City v Fulham, live 4:30pm, 4 February, ESPN

Not got BT Vision? Find out how to get it

More live football fixtures on BT Vision

BT Vision customers can enjoy ESPN for free all weekend between 3 and 5 February. Just go to channel 34. This includes Manchester City v Fulham on 4 February.

Comments

Please leave your comments using the box below. Learn more

  • CH

    How is waving an imaginary card any different to shouting for a foul to be punished from the touchline? I think we’ve seen a lot of the latter in English football from British Managers. Are we saying you’re not allowed to mime? 

  • Del

    Mancini is learning fast about the English game, that it is bent.  What he saw was  an incident that desreved a red card and he should be able to express that, all this fuss about how you should not try to get a player sent off, maybe to a point on the pitch player to player yeah i agree, but as a manager he has a right  to say eh ref that should have been a red card or indeed mime it.  Ferguson has been berating and trying to influence Refs for years.

  • Haver

     

    Maybe he should put both hands and arms in the air and storm
    out of his dug out shouting at the fourth official like SAF as that is clearly
    different. Then instead of just saying ‘I won’t comment’ on decisions in the
    interviews maybe he should do what SAF does i.e. ‘If the assistant referee’s
    ever gets a game again well it’s not up to me to decide’ in reference to
    Newcastle being give a penalty, disgusting behaviour I’m sure most decent
    people will agree. I wonder if that liner ever did work again. Not for him to
    decide indeed but he’ll have a good go at influencing the matter! This is
    common place for SAF. His players dive and cheat they’re constantly caught
    doing this usually Nani because he’s a ‘dirty foreigner’ like Mancini but as
    bigger diver and cheat is Rooney but as he’s British hypocrisy keeps it mostly
    on Nani.

    Some of the decisions against Mancini’s team have been
    really strange especially in the last 4 or 5 games (Barry off against pool for nothing,
     Kompany enough said, Johnson’s worse
    tackle not even getting a yellow in the very next game in fact did it even get
    the foul? and now Figueroa clearly stopping the ball cynically as he could to
    stop Aguero going on goal with the nearest defender 15 yards away) To him it probably
    feels like all the decisions are going  against him decisions you may get once a
    season. One of these decisions could play a part in changing the outcome of
    every English competition it’s not like they are little mistakes the Kompany one
    was massive. Can you blame Mancini for wanting to give his opinions on these?
    He can’t really speak about it as Managers are told not to criticize
    referees in after game interviews, and depending on who you are this gets
    respected. So I guess this is one way he can get his opinion across. A manager
    cannot influence a sending off like a player in the game ala Rooney in the
    derby telling the ref all about a nasty tackle he had seen this of course is no
    problem to the British press and is over looked most weeks but it does seem to
    annoy people a lot more when it is one of those ‘dirty foreigners’ and not the
    British players which doesn’t even warrant a mention and the talk here is about
    hypocrisy. Do me a favour!!

  • Dteacher1uk

    Mike Calvin – your bitterness and crass stupidity is clearly showing. Give it up, you sad little nonentity. You clearly do not have a CLUE!!

  • The TRUTH

    Oh, guess what Mr. Calvin? If you think Mancini has a lot to learn to learn about the English game YET City are top of the Premier League, you must be quaking in your boots as to what will happen when he learns about the English game! You are not the brightest button in the box, are you, Mr. Calvin? As most of the comments below show…

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=772775563 Dan Ethan Martineau

    What crybabies. The man demands his players be protected by punishing
    dangerous or unfair play and HE is the villain. The ridiculous
    hypocrisy of the sporting media knows no limits.

BT is not responsible for any external content or links uploaded by users of the site. Nor does the presence of information or links about other parties' products or services confer any form of endorsement of another party's products or services by BT. Please show respect to other users and avoid bad language when posting